Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) and energy

What 5 graded rows on iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) agree on for energy, and where they differ. Counted side by side, never averaged.

What the rows agree on

Each block and row is one graded row from the Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) page, with its PubMed record.

Your question

Supplement
Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) Choose another

Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) and energy

5 rows · 23,762 people

Split. 3 rows found an improvement, 1 found a worse outcome and 1 had mixed results.

Mixed or worse
Improved
Each block is one evidence row, sized by how many people it enrolled, with its grade inside. Red: a worse outcome. Outlined: mixed results.
  • Grade A× 2
  • Grade B× 1
  • Grade C× 1
  • Grade D× 1
Rows
5
Trials
5
At least: a review without a trial count
People
23,762
Pooled reviews may count some twice

Where they differ

From the rows
Trial sizeWho was studiedWhen published

The best-graded row, grade A, is a meta-analysis of 6,861 people (2016) and found an improvement.

The 3 rows that found an improvement were larger: a median of 6,861 people, against 3,168 people for the row that found a worse outcome.

Only the 3 rows that found an improvement name women in their population.

The 3 rows that found an improvement are newer (2016 to 2024) than the row that found a worse outcome (2015).

1 row with mixed results is left out of this comparison.

The rows

3 improved · 1 worse · 1 mixed
  1. Grade AHemoglobin and iron status in menstruating women · Improved

    Meta-analysis · n 6,861 · 2016 · 51 trials in menstruating women (67 trials, 8506 women overall)

    Varied across trials · Varied across trials

    Hemoglobin was 5.30 g/L higher with iron (high-quality evidence). Iron also lowered the risk of anaemia (RR 0.39; 3273 women) and iron deficiency (RR 0.62; 1088 women), moderate-quality evidence.

    Row on the Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) page · PubMed 27087396 (opens PubMed)

  2. Grade BLow hemoglobin in pregnancy · Improved

    Meta-analysis · n 13,543 · 2024 · 14 trials in pregnant women (57 trials, 48,971 women overall)

    Varied across trials · During pregnancy

    Daily iron may reduce maternal anaemia (4.0% vs 7.4%; RR 0.30), low-certainty evidence, and probably reduces iron-deficiency anaemia at term (RR 0.41), moderate certainty. Evidence on side effects was very uncertain.

    Row on the Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) page · PubMed 39145520 (opens PubMed)

  3. Grade DIron absorption: alternate-day vs consecutive-day · Improved

    RCT · n 40 · 2017 · Iron-depleted women aged 18-40 (serum ferritin ≤25 μg/L)

    60 mg iron per morning, consecutive or alternate days · 14 days (consecutive) vs 28 days (alternate)

    Cumulative fractional absorption was 21.8% on alternate days vs 16.3% on consecutive days, and total absorbed iron 175.3 vs 131.0 mg. In a second study (n=20), splitting 120 mg into two daily doses did not raise absorption.

    Row on the Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) page · PubMed 29032957 (opens PubMed)

  4. Grade AStomach and bowel side effects with ferrous sulfate · Worse

    Meta-analysis · n 3,168 · 2015 · 20 placebo-controlled trials in adults

    Varied across trials · Varied across trials

    Ferrous sulfate raised the odds of gastrointestinal side effects versus placebo (OR 2.32; 95% CI 1.74-3.08). Meta-regression found no clear link with the iron amount.

    Row on the Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) page · PubMed 25700159 (opens PubMed)

  5. Grade CIron stores and side effects: alternate-day vs daily · Mixed

    RCT · n 150 · 2023 · Young Swiss women with serum ferritin ≤30 μg/L

    100 mg iron daily for 90 days vs on alternate days for 180 days (same total) · 6 months

    Ferritin did not differ (43.8 vs 44.8 μg/L). Daily dosing had more gastrointestinal side effects on iron days (LPR 1.56), and iron deficiency at 6 months was 11.4% with daily vs 3.0% with alternate-day dosing.

    Row on the Iron (ferrous sulfate vs bisglycinate vs other forms) page · PubMed 38021373 (opens PubMed)

Educational only. Not medical advice. Some links earn us a commission: kymatahealth.com/affiliate-disclosure.